MCP Gateway Comparison (2026): Composio vs ACP vs DIY
You have MCP servers. They give your model tools. They work on your laptop.
Production needs more: who is calling, what they may do, a record of it, rate limits, PII checks. An MCP gateway sits between the MCP client and the MCP server and applies those controls before the call reaches your backend.
There are three realistic options. Build it yourself on open-source MCP servers, use Composio’s managed integrations, or use ACP (Agentic Control Plane).
This is a snapshot from April 2026. Competitor details come from their public materials at that time. Check Composio’s current docs before you decide, since a product like this changes quickly. The ACP notes were reviewed again in November 2026.
Option 1: Self-hosted (DIY)
Thousands of open-source MCP servers exist for databases, CRMs and file systems. You pick the ones you need, run them yourself and wire them into your agent framework.
You get: full control of the code, the deployment and the data flow. No vendor and no usage fees.
You build: everything else. A raw MCP server doesn’t know who is calling. Every caller gets the same access. There is no audit trail beyond the logging you add, and no rate limits or PII checks unless you write them.
Expect days to weeks for a basic version. You will write JWT validation, policy checks, content scanning, structured logging and per-user rate limits, and repeat it for each server.
Building it is the easy part. Keeping it secure and auditable across ten or more servers as the fleet grows is what costs. Choose this if you need maximum control and have the security engineers to maintain it.
Option 2: Composio
Composio is an integration platform for developers. It advertised 850+ pre-built integrations behind one SDK as of April 2026. Connect an agent to Slack, GitHub, Salesforce or Google Workspace with OAuth and a few lines of code. It supports frameworks like LangChain, CrewAI and Autogen.
If your question is “do you have a connector for this SaaS tool,” they probably do.
It solves the connection problem. Governance is a different job: who may use each connection, what data flows through it, and a record you can show an auditor. As of April 2026, we understood identity there to be API-key based, and tool calls to route through Composio’s infrastructure with no self-host option. That is fine for many teams and a blocker for regulated industries or data residency rules. Confirm both with them.
Buy Composio for speed and coverage. If your main need is identity-based access control and audit, check what it offers for that, and plan to add a layer if it falls short.
Option 3: ACP
ACP starts from the control side. It checks tool calls and logs them, and it adds integrations second.
The part most people use today is a hook for coding agents (Claude Code, Cursor, Codex and others). Each tool call, including MCP tool calls, goes to ACP before it runs. ACP answers allow, ask or deny and writes one log. See the coverage page for which harnesses are supported and how deep the enforcement goes. ACP also serves its own MCP endpoint at https://api.agenticcontrolplane.com/mcp.
For servers you run yourself, the open-source GatewayStack packages are separate building blocks:
- identifiabl verifies JWTs against Auth0, Okta, Entra ID, Firebase or another OIDC provider, so each call carries a verified user.
- transformabl detects PII in tool inputs and outputs.
- explicabl writes structured audit logs with identity, tool, decision and outcome.
- limitabl applies per-user and per-agent rate limits.
- proxyabl blocks tool calls that reach internal network addresses.
There is also a managed version at cloud.agenticcontrolplane.com.
What to know before you pick it:
- The built-in connector catalog is small compared with Composio’s. For anything else you connect a custom MCP server.
- A new workspace starts in audit mode. Calls are recorded and only the safety floor holds anything. You turn on your own rules when you are ready.
- ACP runs as a hook on the machine running the agent. If hooks are turned off, it stops checking.
- Rules key on the tool, such as
Bash.rmor a given MCP tool. They don’t read inside every MCP server’s arguments. The safety floor looks at shell command text only.
Side by side (April 2026)
| Self-hosted | Composio | ACP | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Integrations | Whatever you deploy | 850+ advertised | Small built-in set plus custom MCP |
| Identity | You build it | API keys, as we understood | JWT with your identity provider (GatewayStack) |
| PII detection | You build it | Check their docs | Recognised credential formats are redacted in stored previews; PII detection is in the transformabl package |
| Audit trail | You build it | Check their docs | One log of every governed call |
| Rate limits | You build it | Check their docs | Per tier in the console |
| Open source | Depends | Check their docs | GatewayStack packages, yes |
| Self-host | Yes | No, as we understood | Yes |
| Hosted option | No | Yes | Yes |
When to use each
Self-hosted: you need maximum control and can staff it. It suits internal tools where you own both the agents and the backends and no outside auditor is asking.
Composio: you want speed. Prototypes, MVPs and internal developer tools where the goal is to get the agent doing useful things now.
ACP: agents touch sensitive data, or you need to answer “who did what, and is there a record.” That is the fit for compliance questions and for teams whose agents run with nobody watching.
Can you combine them?
Yes. They do different jobs.
ACP can sit in front of self-hosted MCP servers. The servers don’t change. Composio can handle the connections to hundreds of services while ACP checks and records the calls your agents make. One handles connections, the other handles checks.
Making the decision
If you want the most services connected with the least effort, choose Composio.
If you want to own every component, build it yourself and plan the engineering time.
If you need identity-based access control and a log of every call, choose ACP, either as the open-source packages or the managed cloud.
Most teams end up needing all three jobs done. Start with the one that hurts most.
The free tier covers up to 5 initiating agents.
Try ACP Cloud free -> · GatewayStack on GitHub -> · Reference architecture ->
Running coding agents? ACP records each tool call its hook sees and makes the dangerous shell commands (a force-push, destructive SQL, curl | sh) wait for you. One command, free up to 5 agents:
curl -fsSL https://agenticcontrolplane.com/install.sh | bash
irm https://agenticcontrolplane.com/install.ps1 | iex
- 3. MCP Server Audit Logging: I Checked 8,216 Servers. 74.9% Don't Mention It.
- 5. MCP Gateway Comparison (2026): Composio vs ACP vs DIY · you are here
- 6. MCP Security Vulnerabilities: 4 Tool Schema Patterns Behind Real CVEs